Monetizing Infringement

Authors

Kristelia García, University of Colorado Law SchoolFollow

Document Type

Article

Publication

U.C. Davis Law Review

Year

2020

Citation Information

Kristelia García, Monetizing Infringement, 54 U.C. Davis L. Rev. 265 (2020), available at https://scholar.law.colorado.edu/faculty-articles/1308.

Abstract

The deterrence of copyright infringement and the evils of piracy have long been an axiomatic focus of both legislators and scholars. The conventional view is that infringement must be curbed and/or punished in order for copyright to fulfill its purported goals of incentivizing creation and ensuring access to works. This Essay proves this view false by demonstrating that some rightsholders don’t merely tolerate, but actually encourage infringement, both explicitly and implicitly, in a variety of different situations and for one common reason: they benefit from it. Rightsholders’ ability to monetize infringement destabilizes long-held but problematic assumptions about both rightsholder preferences, and about copyright’s optimal infringement policy.

Through a series of case studies, this Essay describes the impetuses and normative implications of this counterintuitive — but not so unusual — phenomenon. Recognition of monetized infringement in copyright is interesting not only for its unexpectedness, but also for the broader point that its existence suggests: we have an impoverished descriptive account of why some laws operate the way that they do. This is particularly unsettling in an area like copyright, where advocates are sharply divided along policy lines. This Essay is an important first step toward a positive theory of copyright — one that recognizes the underappreciated role, both positive and negative, that private parties play in policymaking.

Comments

"Copyright © 2020 Kristelia García."

Copyright Statement

Copyright protected. Use of materials from this collection beyond the exceptions provided for in the Fair Use and Educational Use clauses of the U.S. Copyright Law may violate federal law. Permission to publish or reproduce is required.